Lesson 3.6

The Hidden Rules of the Economic Classes

Male employee smiling

Lesson Preparation

Before coming to your training, please do the following:

 

Lesson Preview

At times, it is hard to know what gaps of knowledge and experience people have to fill in order to become self-reliant. It helps to know some of their background so that you can help them fill those gaps. Understanding a person’s socioeconomic background can give you insights into how to help that person. In this lesson, you will (1) become familiar with the patterns of two different economic classes, (2) make plans to strengthen your support system so that you can achieve one of your ATI goals, and (3) take these tools and apply them in your own life, as well as in your work with at least one of your associates.

Note: Remember that people come from all different circumstances and respond differently to their situations. While there may be some trends in how people from different socioeconomic classes might behave, it’s important to remember individuality. For example, a person who is highly educated and moves to the United States but speaks limited English will likely approach situations very differently from someone who has grown up in poverty in the United States, even if they make similar salaries.


Hidden Rules of Lower and Middle Economic Classes

From the following list, choose and complete one or more activities that best apply to your situation.

Read Icon
Activity 1

Review “The Hidden Rules of the Economic Classes,” and then read the class sketches included in the “Lesson Resources” section, Resource 1. As a group, try to identify which class each speaker likely belongs to.

After identifying the different socioeconomic backgrounds, discuss the following questions:

  • Overall, how can economic class influence the way these individuals think and behave?
  • How might these labels be a constraint to these individuals?
  • Is either of these economic classes better than the other? Why or why not?
  • How could it be helpful to think of these “hidden rules” as patterns instead of set rules?
  • Why is it incorrect to assume that everyone from a certain economic background will behave the same way? How can thinking of these patterns as set rules hamper your work?
  • Consider your own experience with your associates. Have you witnessed any of these attitudes? How could these attitudes impact your associates’ development?

Group Icon
Activity 2

As a group, review “The Hidden Rules of the Economic Classes,” and choose four or five items you would like to focus on. Divide into pairs or small groups. Each group should focus on one or two items. Then come together and share what you have discussed with the class.

Discuss the following questions after completing the exercise:

  • Why is it important to not label classes as better or worse than the other?
  • What privileges do people from the middle class experience that the lower class might not enjoy? What attitudes might the lower class have that the middle class does not enjoy? How can these differences be educational for both classes?
  • Why is it helpful to think of these “hidden rules” as socioeconomic patterns instead of set rules for how people behave?
  • How can understanding someone’s background help you as you coach that individual?
  • What are some attitudes that you have observed in current or former associates? How can understanding their background help you understand those attitudes?
  • How can becoming aware of these patterns help you identify an associate’s knowledge gap or need?
  • How can identifying these gaps allow you to create action steps to help an associate become self-reliant?

Group Icon
Activity 3

Divide into small groups. Play the sorting game found in the “Lesson Resources” section, Resource 2. The groups will compete to correctly sort the squares into two piles (lower class or middle class). The first group to correctly sort the squares wins.

Consider the following questions as a group:

  • How easy or difficult was it to recognize different economic classes as you were sorting?
  • How easy or difficult would it be to recognize these attitudes in real life?
  • How might it help you to understand and recognize these attitudes in those you work with?
  • How might it help you to understand and recognize these attitudes in yourself?
  • Why is it important to not label classes as better or worse than the other?
  • What privileges do people from the middle class experience that the lower class might not enjoy? What attitudes might the lower class have that the middle class does not enjoy? How can these differences be educational for both classes?
  • Why would it be helpful to think of these “hidden rules” as patterns instead of set rules?
  • What are some attitudes that you have observed in current or former associates? How can understanding their background help you understand those attitudes?

Identify Your Support System So You Can Accomplish Your Goals

Elder L. Tom Perry said, “The spheres of influence we can radiate from our associations can make worthwhile contributions in the world” (“In the World,” Ensign, May 1988, 15). This section will discuss social capital and support systems (how others can support us in reaching our goals, as well as how we can support others).

From the following list, choose and complete one or more activities that best apply to your situation.

Group Icon
Activity 1

Read the following statement:

“Having social capital is not simply about how many people you know, how close you feel to them, or how many arrangements you have made with them. Rather, social capital is about where your contacts are within a social structure as well as the quality of their resources, including their own social capital (connections to others). Social capital is what we draw on when we get others, whether acquaintances, friends, or kin, to help us solve problems, seize opportunities, and accomplish other aims” (Deseret Employment update, third quarter [2014]).

Divide into small groups. Each group will choose a person to be “Taylor” in a role-play. This person will step out of the room for a moment. After Taylor has stepped out of the room, the remaining group members will be assigned a number between one and ten (each number should be different). The number assigned represents the social capital contact that each group member represents for Taylor (see Resource 3 of the “Lesson Resources” section). Each individual will then receive one item of currency from the Social Capital Handout (see Resource 4 of the “Lesson Resources” section). Individuals will write down which social capital contact they are, as well as a dollar amount from $1 to $10, based on how valuable they feel they would be as a resource to Taylor in getting a job at the factory.

Once this is finished, invite Taylor to return and give him or her the following instructions:

You want a job at the local factory in town. You are in need of a job and have to find a good lead quickly. You will approach a few group members for potential networking. Each time you approach a group member, that person will give you paper currency that shows how likely you are to get the position based on that connection. Your goal is to collect the highest amount of social capital. Due to time constraints, you will only be able to approach three individuals today. After you are done asking three individuals for help, compare the money received with the other Taylors in the meeting. Whoever has the most social capital wins the job.

After completing the activity, discuss the following questions as a group:

  • How well did your group’s Taylor utilize his or her available social capital?
  • Why is social capital relevant to associates and job coach trainers?
  • Which person in your group was in the position to offer the greatest value of social capital? Is there a connection between social capital and a person’s job level and salary? Why or why not?
  • Which of the individuals listed in Resource 3 of the “Lesson Resources” section would be the most valuable for Taylor?

Write Icon
Activity 2

Use the “My Support for Change Plan” and the “Support for Change” diagram in Resource 5 of the “Lesson Resources” section to complete this activity. Use the example shown for “Molly” as a reference.

Part 1: Take a minute to identify individually an existing ATI goal that represents a major change for you. On the “My Support for Change Plan,” write your goal in the space provided. Then, write the names of people that might support your change and how you think they can help you (cheer you up, follow-up, counsel you, etc.). Ask the people you thought of to support you in your goal.

Part 2: After people commit to support you, complete the “Support for Change” diagram. Write your goal in the space provided next to “My Goal.” Write your name in the diagram’s center circle. Write the names of those who have committed to support your goal in the circles surrounding your name on the diagram.

Draw a line between each person’s name and yourself—the more support he or she is likely to give you, the thicker the line should be. Put the diagram in a place where you can see it often and use it as a tool to help you work on your goal.

Regroup with all attendees and discuss:

  • Who can help you reach your ATI goal and how can they help you reach it? (Share one or two people you wrote on your diagram.)
  • How important is it to have support from other people when working toward a goal?
  • How could doing a similar activity with one of your associates help him or her progress toward self-reliance?

Group Icon
Activity 3

Separate into three groups, called A, B, and C. Each group will be assigned a situation to discuss from the situations in the “Lesson Resources” section, Resource 6. Begin with the scenarios in part 1 of the activity. Answer the following questions about your assigned situation:

  • How much of an impact could increased support have on the individual in this situation?
  • Without that support, what are the difficulties that the individual might face in making the needed changes?
  • What kind of support could be extended to the individual to help him or her change?

After this discussion, read each group’s explanation from part 2 of the activity.

  • What struck you the most from seeing the end results of these stories?
  • What lessons can we learn from these stories and this activity?

Ponder and Plan

“What Lack I Yet?”

Seek to identify a personal or business gap or need.

Spend a few minutes silently pondering what you've discussed during this lesson. Listen as the Holy Ghost helps you identify areas where you can improve. Record your impressions in your learner's journal under the question “What Lack I Yet?”

“What Must I Do?”

Seek ways to close the gap or develop the required talent(s) to meet the need.

With the guidance of the Spirit, create your plan of how you will improve and close the gap(s) you have identified. You may use one or more of the exercises below, your own strategy, or a combination of both. Record this plan in your learner's journal under “What Must I Do?”

  • Create a plan to become familiar with the patterns of economic classes in the United States. Then carry out your plan throughout the week. Observe an associate’s behavior, as well as things they say. Talk to a fellow job coach trainer or a supervisor and discuss the possible gaps this associate may have, according to the hidden rules of economic classes, as well as what you could do to help the associate fill in those gaps.
  • Create a plan on how three individuals from your “Support Team Pool” list can help you achieve your goal. Share it with them, and ask for their support.

After a few minutes, those who are comfortable doing so can share their impressions with the group.

“Therefore, What?”

Seek understanding, and then share what you learned.

During the week, focus on implementing the plan you created. Record your impressions or lessons learned in your learner's journal under “Therefore, What?” You will be given time at the beginning of next week's lesson to share your experience with the group.

“Poverty [is] the ‘extent to which an individual does without resources.’ … However, the reality is that financial resources, while extremely important, do not explain the differences in the success with which some individuals leave poverty nor the reasons that many stay in poverty. The ability to leave poverty is more dependent upon other resources than it is upon financial resources.”

Ruby K. Payne and others, Bridges out of Poverty (2001), 11–12

Lesson Resources

Resource 1

Class Sketches

Example 1: Clothing

Carl: I may not have a lot of outfits, but the ones I do wear are top notch. I just wouldn’t feel right walking around with my friends in something out of a department store.

Example 2: Social Emphasis

Joseph: I never felt I was the center of any group. I do always try to have a story or joke to use with my coworkers. Those moments when I get them to react are just the highlights of my day! It helps me feel like I belong.

Example 3: What Drives Me

Alice: When I’m not visiting family, most of my week I’m just trying to get by. I can’t wait to spend time out with my girls this weekend! We’re going dancing!

Example 4: Prized Possessions

Jill: I just got a cute little car to get me to work. One of my girlfriends has one just like it, except hers has leather seats. I think I’m going to see how much it costs to upgrade. I sat in hers the other day and it felt wonderful!

Example 5: School

Yasir: Of course I’m going to continue my education! I plan to major in engineering. I just need to focus on other things right now, like putting food on the table and paying the rent. Maybe I’ll go back to school in a few years.

Example 6: The Future

Evelina: Every day this week I’ve been working on the project my boss assigned. If I can impress her with this I think she’ll take me on as her assistant—or even a project manager! I think I’ll stay late today to get a little extra work done.

Example 7: Food

Gary: I love buffets! I get as much as I want, and I’m always stuffed afterwards. I don’t have to worry about them skimping on the servings.

Example 8: Money

Wilma: I’ve always been good at keeping track of our money, so my husband lets me handle the bills. It’s how I was brought up.

Example 9: Power

Evelia: The other day I ran into an old friend that had been struggling to make ends meet. She felt like everything was against her. I could have just wished her the best and walked on, but I could see how difficult this had been for her. We sat for over an hour talking, and I convinced her to look into a great program I’d heard about through my work.

Example 10: Family Structure

Godofredo: When grandmother speaks, we all listen. She told me what school I should attend, and what job I should pursue. She even told me what kind of wife I needed. My wife is going to be a lot like grandmother.


Answers

Example 1: Middle

Example 2: Lower

Example 3: Lower

Example 4: Middle

Example 5: Lower

Example 6: Middle

Example 7: Lower

Example 8: Middle

Example 9: Middle

Example 10: Lower



Resource 2

Sorting Game

Facilitator: See instructions in the Facilitator’s Guide.


Resource 3

The following individuals represent Taylor’s social capital.

  1. 1 Taylor’s father: Friends with the line foreman at the local factory.
  2. 2 Taylor’s best friend: Works in another department at the factory as a line worker.
  3. 3 Taylor’s distant relative two times removed: Owns the entire company.
  4. 4 Random acquaintance: Taylor bumps into this random person every week at the gym. This person works in the administrative office at the factory.
  5. 5 Taylor’s high school buddy: Hasn’t spoken to Taylor since high school, but they used to joke around together in the back of the class during English. Taylor thinks he’s on the social media team at the factory, if he can remember his last name.
  6. 6 Taylor’s kindergarten teacher: Taylor found his or her teacher on social media. The teacher likes to post about cats.
  7. 7 Taylor’s doctor: Knows everybody in town.
  8. 8 Taylor’s girlfriend’s sister: Met one of the boss’s single children at a party last weekend, and thought he was “kinda cute.”
  9. 9 Taylor’s brother: Would do anything for Taylor. Just loves Taylor to death.
  10. 10 Taylor’s neighbor: Does something for the factory and seems fairly well-off.

Resource 4


Resource 5





Resource 6

Part 1
  1. A. The first example is a child who had an extremely unhappy home life. His family moved from one state to another until he was eight years old. He was often beaten by his father, who was either too strict or not strict enough, according to his mood at the time. The boy spent many of his early years sleeping in buses, train stations, and cheap hotels. At age fourteen, he was arrested as a runaway. Both family and friends classified him as untrustworthy, violent, and a loner.
  2. B. The second example is a boy who was frail at birth. Throughout his childhood he had a tendency toward infection. His frail body seemed unable to hold his oversized head. His father worried that people considered his son “addled,” and on one occasion he beat the boy publicly. Because his mother had lost three previous children, she wrapped herself in black and withdrew from others.
  3. C. In the third example, a young man came from circumstances of near-poverty. His family was forced to move more than once because of financial difficulties. He had little, if any, formal schooling. His mother reported that he was less inclined to read and study than any of the other children. Because neighbors considered many of his ways and ideas strange, his peers ostracized him. All of his life he was hounded by the law and found himself constantly in difficulty.
Part 2
  1. A. The first young man’s life was a series of continuing arrests for everything from vagrancy to armed robbery and murder. Never recognizing the need to change, he was one day convicted of murder.
  2. B. The second was a description of the early years of Thomas A. Edison. From a beginning that seemed almost too much to overcome, he was able to change and build. Though he was once thought to be mentally handicapped, he proved himself to be one of the greatest inventors of all time. His personal commitment changed the whole world for the better.
  3. C. The third tells the story of a young man and his early days in the northeastern part of this country. He was born in 1805 during a hard and cold Vermont winter. His name was Joseph Smith, and his beginnings were difficult. Life was a series of struggles—not only physically but also emotionally and spiritually. But here was a young man who recognized the need for improvement through change and submitted to an authority greater than himself. From tremendously difficult beginnings he sought change and ushered in the last dispensation. His faith, prayers, and works brought to the earth the greatest, most profound changes in the latter days.

From Marvin J. Ashton, “Progress through Change,” Conference Report, Oct. 1979, 86–90.

Print Icon
Print Icon
Print Icon
Print Icon